|
The Charpy V-notch specimen for all surface treatments
tested is shown above. This test measures the amount of energy that is needed to
break this sample V-notch bar. In general, the impact resistance and fracture
toughness or gross cracking resistance are inversely proportional to the
hardness. Lower toughness is attributed to high hardness at the surface. It has
been found that Charpy values exceeding 15 joules (11 ft.-lbs) are desirable in
practical die casting. The low temperature surface treatments tested, such as
Nitrotec, ion nitriding, and Melonite (a non-toxic form of Tufftriding) had only
a range of 2.5 to 7 ft.- lbs with an average of 3 to 4.4 ft.-lbs. This is
significantly lower than the tested conventionally machined and ground notch
specimen that exhibited an average of 12.5 ft. Ibs.
As expected all of the
MetaLL
ife
samples for both the E2 and E5 EDM methods, whether or not polished and/or
tempered afterwards, showed a higher impact energy than that of the ground
surface or low temperature surface treatments. For undetermined reasons there
was somewhat less of an improvement on the high intensity (H.l.M) E2 samples
that had been tempered (T) and polished (P). Electropolishing also showed an
increase in impact strength but not as much as the
MetaLL
ife
samples.
CONCLUSIONS
Previous testing of H-13 materials has shown that dies
receiving the
MetaLL
ifeÒ
process have a much greater resistance to heat checking and thermal fatigue This
is true whether it be applied to a NEW or USED tool. This test now confirms
that,in the case of EDM H-13 material, the resistance to gross cracking is also
increased by the application of
MetaLL
ifeÒ.
These average increases in impact energy were found to be anywhere from 23.2% to
39.2% greater than that for a machined and ground surface. The poor thermal
fatigue resistance of the ion nitriding and Nitrotec treatments is attributed to
the brittleness of the compound zone consisting of FE4N/FE2N3 in the ion
nitrided sample and FE3N in the Nitrotec sample. The Melonite sample also had
significantly reduced Charpy impact strength.
If the die caster desires resistance to gross cracking and increased resistance
to fatigue cracking,
MetaLL
ifeÒ
is the most effective surface treatment to apply to EDM or milled/ground
surfaces. In addition, none of the other surface treatments have the ability to
close existing cracks in die surfaces to keep them from further propagating. The
die caster therefore has two choices for longer die life: he can PREVENT IT NOW-
to extend his new tool life. or RESTORE IT LATER- to obtain additional life from
dies that are already heat checked.
Click HERE for the
H13 Thermal Stress Dip Tank Test.
You may
download or print a hard copy of the EDM test along with other
brochures.
|